_GOTOBOTTOM
Constructive Feedback
For in-progress or completed build photos. Give and get contructive feedback!
Tamiya 1/35 M5A1 OOB (Almost)
Damraska
Visit this Community
California, United States
Joined: October 06, 2006
KitMaker: 580 posts
Armorama: 499 posts
Posted: Saturday, January 24, 2009 - 10:04 AM UTC
For your viewing pleasure I present Tamiya's 1/35 scale M5A1 Stuart light tank built out of the box...almost.

I often find myself going long stretches between painting sessions with an airbrush, and thus my painting skills lack in comparison to other areas. The best way to improve a skill is to practice, so I decided to build a couple quick models, putting the emphasis on painting rather than super-detailing.

My weapon of choice for this painting experiment was Tamiya's 1/35 M5A1 Staurt, purchased for $3US at a my club's annual model auction. The model has a number of accuracy issues including the dread dimensional problems--it is squished lengthwise. The tracks also include a major flaw--the guide horns do not connect adjacent pads as they should. Since my goal was to paint rather than build, I chose to overlook the first issue. I easily remedied the second issue by raiding an Academy M3A1 for much more accurate band tracks. The Academy kit comes with both individual link and band tracks, so this theft left me with a complete model. While I was in the Academy box, I also grabbed the dished road wheels. I forget why I did this, but it made sense at the time.

Construction followed the kit directions with one major and one minor diversion. As with most Tamiya armor kits of its generation, this one does not include sponson floors so I added some using plastic card. This allowed me the option of leaving off the track guards. While I was in there, I also blanked off the motor holes in the bottom of the hull. Since this was a painting exercise I put no further effort into that issue. While building up the turret I decided to try a new technique for making welds--small diameter plastic rod shaved to a hemispheric cross section. I did not melt the rod and smear it out with a pin so it looks rather unrealistic. Did I mention this was a painting experiment? The last modification was blanking plates for the idler wheels.

The tracks did not respond to Testors liquid cement or Super Glue so I heat smashed the pins and put two staples in each one for good measure. Test fitting indicated I could hide the staples in the running gear.

After about 10 hours it was off to the paint shop. Early on I decided to model Victory, an olive drab M5A1 assigned to the 3rd Armored Division in Northwest Europe. This decal scheme comes in the box and I did not have any replacements at the time. The 3rd Armored Division regularly used black as camouflage over olive drab, so I also decided to give this a try. I have no evidence Victory wore such camouflage, but as I may have mentioned, this was a painting experiment.

The standard match for US WWII OD is Tamiya XF-62, an acrylic paint. I paint with enamels and chose to fudge an approximation using a Testors British olive drab intended for aircraft. With the base coat in place I began adding streaks and dappling using four or five olive drab variants mixed on the fly. This process adds lots of contrast and depth to the monotone scheme without looking overly faded. I finished off the hull and turret with soft edge black stripes using flat black. The airbrush sputtered while laying down the stripes, but I decided to tackle that in weathering.

The tracks were painted flat black then dappled with burnt umber, raw sienna, and armor sand in succession from darkest to lightest.

A few days later I came back and hit every surface receiving a decal with Testors gloss acrylic overcoat. A few days after that I added the decals. The kit decals, though very thick, laid down fine with some Micro Set. After the decals set up I sealed the entire model with a custom mixed semi-gloss acrylic clear coat (more flat than gloss). I also used the airbrush to weather the bottom of the tank as described for the tracks.

With all primary painting completed I started in on the detail painting and finished up the road wheels using--you guessed it--flat black. I also went ahead and mounted the drive sprockets and tracks.

At this point I moved and the model ended up in storage for about 6 months. This gave lots of time for the paint to cure. In that 6 months I learned quite a bit, completed three other armor models, and developed a whole new list of techniques to try. Before trying those techniques on something involved I decided to pull out my old painting experiment.

Before any weathering I painted all the tools, gun barrels, track teeth, and added the track guards. For the tools I used Testors Wood followed by Burnt Sienna (deep golden stain), Armor Sand (bleached wood), or Burnt Unmber (deep brown stain). The metal parts of the tools were painted Flat Black or Olive Drab. I used the colors above in various combinations to create as much visual contrast as possible. The gun barrels received flat black coats. The track teeth were very lightly dry brushed with Oiled Steel.

I began weathering with a heavy wash of Winsor and Newton Burnt Umber oil paint heavily diluted with Mona Lisa odorless mineral spirits. I added extra doses as required, cleaned up pools, and generally moved the oil paint around as desired. Oil paint works so well in this application because you can "tweak" it again and again until it looks just so. When finished, I put the model aside for a few days.

One thing I wanted to try on this model was rust. I am not a huge fan of the hairspray method because of bad experiences with Testors Metalizers and lifting paint. I am also not a huge fan of rust buckets. The solution--I beat the hell out of the hedgegrow cutter with a sponge. I started by sponging Oiled Steel onto the cutter, especially along the edges. I did not use the silver anywhere else on the model. Next came Raw Umber, then Raw Sienna, and finally Burnt Sienna. These colors were lightly sponged all over the model, but only where the crew would stand or rub.

At this point the cutter looked pretty good and the weathering--okay. What the model needed was some more contrast to counter all those dark colors, so I began to dry brush. The first round, with Faded Olive Drab, hit just about every raised surface on the entire model. Next, I mixed the Faded Olive Drab with some Earth Yellow and did it again, this time keeping to the upper surfaces. Some more Earth Yellow and then round three on prominent features. Yet more Earth Yellow and round four on the most prominent features.

The next step was a spot wash using Rust All, applied here and there (and everywhere on the cutter). In a few cases, when the effect was just too pronounced, I went back and cleaned up the rust by dry brushing some faded olive drab over it.

At this point I would normally add a clear coat to seal it all in; instead I took some pictures. The pictures revealed that the model was really alive--much more alive than anything else on my shelf. No clear coat.

With no overall clear coat I needed to tone down some of the tools so I painted all the black and olive drab parts with a 3/4 flat acrylic clear coat. I also added a gloss coat to the headlight and taillight lenses. In the latter case that may have been a mistake.

The pictures also revealed some flaws--a fingerprint in the paint, problems with the whip antenna, and a few painting issues. The painting issues were cleaned up with spot drybrushing using the base color. To fix the whip antenna I cut off the very top of the US antenna base, replaced it with a section of rod, drilled out a hole for the antenna, put the antenna back in, and painted it. For the fingerprint, I used an Xacto knife and scraped down through the paint coats until it was flat. Bet ya can't figure out where it was!

I also needed to do something with the spotlight. Why oh why did I turn it up? They're never turned up. A punched disk of aluminum foil followed by a punched disk of clear acetate fixed that problem.

What now? I made some fuel spill stains with Black Wash but they mostly disappeared on the black camouflage stripes. I also fixed a few track teeth with more Oiled Steel. The barrels received a dusting of ground pencil lead. A standard mechanical pencil contributed some nicks, scratches, and dings.

After looking at the model a long time I decided not to use pigments on the tracks and running gear. I think they would kill a really interesting effect that somehow congealed out of this experiment.

All feedback welcome. Enjoy!

-Doug



The antenna was made using a cat whisker--another first for me. This may be the only thing a cat is good for.





Love those thick decals. I hit the grousers with quite a bit of rust to liven up the turret--probably too much.





The hedgegrow cutter turned out very well. The extra thick headlight guards look particularly stunning.



The streaking on the side of the turret came out very well, though probably overdone. The fuel stains disappeared on the black stripes. I did not replace the grab handles with wire!



The welds added to the roof lack the flowing texture of real welds. Still, this technique works well in hard to reach places.
BigfootV
Visit this Community
Colorado, United States
Joined: December 24, 2005
KitMaker: 1,624 posts
Armorama: 994 posts
Posted: Saturday, January 24, 2009 - 10:11 AM UTC
I see red xxxxx's, no photo.
BigfootV
Visit this Community
Colorado, United States
Joined: December 24, 2005
KitMaker: 1,624 posts
Armorama: 994 posts
Posted: Saturday, January 24, 2009 - 01:18 PM UTC
O.K., I can see them now. User error on my end.

Looks good Doug.
DT61
Visit this Community
Ontario, Canada
Joined: September 18, 2005
KitMaker: 1,226 posts
Armorama: 819 posts
Posted: Saturday, January 24, 2009 - 03:01 PM UTC
Lools really good.

Darryl
Damraska
Visit this Community
California, United States
Joined: October 06, 2006
KitMaker: 580 posts
Armorama: 499 posts
Posted: Saturday, January 24, 2009 - 09:26 PM UTC

Quoted Text

O.K., I can see them now. User error on my end.



Hi Brian,

Not your error. I could not get the pictures located on the Kitmaker Network to load. I had to host them elsewhere and recode the image URLs. There's no preview function so I had to fire off the post, see the busted pictures just like you, then go back and fix them.

Brian and Darryl, thank you for your comments. Next time I will try to post something more worthy of attention.

-Doug
FredRMA
Visit this Community
California, United States
Joined: March 01, 2006
KitMaker: 72 posts
Armorama: 66 posts
Posted: Saturday, January 24, 2009 - 09:41 PM UTC
I have this kit in my stash, cheap off ebay. I opened it looked at it and wondered how the heck I was going to get it to look good. You have made it look perfect. Very impressive build and I will refer to your "build notes" when painting wood on my own kits
Very nicely done
Red4
Visit this Community
California, United States
Joined: April 01, 2002
KitMaker: 4,287 posts
Armorama: 1,867 posts
Posted: Saturday, January 24, 2009 - 09:51 PM UTC
Doug, looks good. Some suggestions for fuels stains in the future, or if you want to add them to it now. Use your oils again. The Raw Umber to be precise. Just thin it enough to get a good flow, but not too thin and you can manipulate it around to create some very nice fuel stains that will show up on the black. The real spills would have attracted dirt and dust and had this same look. I know I had them on my 1:1 Bradley when it was all green and they stood out pretty well. Agree with you about the hedgerow cutter, looks great Another suggestion if you don't mind, mix up some thinned tan, like really thinned, and mist it along your suspension components and lower hull. Creates a nice dusting effect that allows the underlying weathering to show thru. If you get it too heavy you can always go back and touch things up with some pin washes. You can impart scratches in the paint too with a tooth pick. SImply drag it down the sides of the hull, It won't so much scratch the paint, but sort of polish where it touches, creating a different color that is visible and appears as a scratch. You are right though, the only way to improve is to keep at it. I like it. Post some more pics as you continue. Thanks for sharing. "Q"
sgtreef
Visit this Community
Oklahoma, United States
Joined: March 01, 2002
KitMaker: 6,043 posts
Armorama: 4,347 posts
Posted: Saturday, January 24, 2009 - 11:59 PM UTC

Quoted Text

Doug, looks good. Some suggestions for fuels stains in the future, or if you want to add them to it now. Use your oils again. The Raw Umber to be precise. Just thin it enough to get a good flow, but not too thin and you can manipulate it around to create some very nice fuel stains that will show up on the black. The real spills would have attracted dirt and dust and had this same look. I know I had them on my 1:1 Bradley when it was all green and they stood out pretty well. Agree with you about the hedgerow cutter, looks great Another suggestion if you don't mind, mix up some thinned tan, like really thinned, and mist it along your suspension components and lower hull. Creates a nice dusting effect that allows the underlying weathering to show thru. If you get it too heavy you can always go back and touch things up with some pin washes. You can impart scratches in the paint too with a tooth pick. SImply drag it down the sides of the hull, It won't so much scratch the paint, but sort of polish where it touches, creating a different color that is visible and appears as a scratch. You are right though, the only way to improve is to keep at it. I like it. Post some more pics as you continue. Thanks for sharing. "Q"




First great job on the build Doug.
You have captured the look of the real one very well.
The tracks you could of used a set of AFV Club as they make them and very Cheap to use.
Again nice finish and build.

Red 4 have you ever heard of an Oil Paint called "Asphalt" seems what most of the Folks in Spain use for Fuel stains.

Good job.
Red4
Visit this Community
California, United States
Joined: April 01, 2002
KitMaker: 4,287 posts
Armorama: 1,867 posts
Posted: Sunday, January 25, 2009 - 12:43 AM UTC

Quoted Text

Red 4 have you ever heard of an Oil Paint called "Asphalt" seems what most of the Folks in Spain use for Fuel stains

Nope. Haven't heard of that one. Will look into it though. Thanks, "Q"
alfa10
Visit this Community
Massachusetts, United States
Joined: January 15, 2009
KitMaker: 121 posts
Armorama: 120 posts
Posted: Sunday, January 25, 2009 - 01:27 AM UTC
Looks great...especially the cat whisker.
Damraska
Visit this Community
California, United States
Joined: October 06, 2006
KitMaker: 580 posts
Armorama: 499 posts
Posted: Sunday, January 25, 2009 - 04:05 AM UTC

Quoted Text

I have this kit in my stash, cheap off ebay. I opened it looked at it and wondered how the heck I was going to get it to look good. You have made it look perfect. Very impressive build and I will refer to your "build notes" when painting wood on my own kits
Very nicely done



Thank you very much, Fred.

For painting the wood, enamels and oils work best for the "staining" stage. They don't dry nearly as fast as acrylics so you can work them around to get the degree of "streakiness" you want.

One more pearl of wisdom--if you use the track guards, have them ready to test fit when you install the bogie trucks. On each guard, two small plates hang down and bolt to the tops of the trucks. On my build the plates do not line up perfectly. The idler assemblies also want to sit high or low, so make extra sure to keep everything level when assembling the running gear.

-Doug
Damraska
Visit this Community
California, United States
Joined: October 06, 2006
KitMaker: 580 posts
Armorama: 499 posts
Posted: Sunday, January 25, 2009 - 04:15 AM UTC

Quoted Text

Use your oils again. The Raw Umber to be precise. ... mix up some thinned tan, like really thinned, and mist it along your suspension components and lower hull. ... You can impart scratches in the paint too with a tooth pick.



Great feedback and suggestions, "Q". I'm going to try all three techniques on an old Panzer II. If I get decent results, ditto for the Stuart. Thanks!

-Doug
Damraska
Visit this Community
California, United States
Joined: October 06, 2006
KitMaker: 580 posts
Armorama: 499 posts
Posted: Sunday, January 25, 2009 - 04:21 AM UTC

Quoted Text

The tracks you could of used a set of AFV Club as they make them and very Cheap to use. ... Red 4 have you ever heard of an Oil Paint called "Asphalt" seems what most of the Folks in Spain use for Fuel stains.



Thank you, Jeff.

I agree that the AFV Club Stuart band tracks look better that the Academy ones. When I originally built this up I did not have any of the latter. I do now, and they will become part of another experiment. For a "real" project I would use the AFV Club individual link tracks.

I will look for that paint as well. Oil and fuel stains tend to look a bit different, so more options are better.

Thanks!

-Doug
BigfootV
Visit this Community
Colorado, United States
Joined: December 24, 2005
KitMaker: 1,624 posts
Armorama: 994 posts
Posted: Sunday, January 25, 2009 - 04:32 AM UTC
Doug,

Your work got my attention that's why I said something. Your selling yourself short. Far better than the one I've built.
I too run into the same challange with the skirts not fitting correctly with the bogies. I correct this by cutting that area out and placing the fender ends on only.
Another challange was the gun mantle for the 37mm, this doesn't want to stay in one place. It looks like I modeled it to be knocked out, barrel pointing down.

The paint is way better than anything I'll ever do.
As a matter of fact I'm going to have to do a rebuild because I found it on the floor of the garage on Friday.
According to the wife, a mouse tried to steal it and wage war on her cats.
marsiascout
Visit this Community
Noord-Brabant, Netherlands
Joined: March 24, 2008
KitMaker: 1,247 posts
Armorama: 913 posts
Posted: Sunday, January 25, 2009 - 06:33 AM UTC
Nice work! The only thing I don't like are those stripy dust? marks on the sides.

Lars
Damraska
Visit this Community
California, United States
Joined: October 06, 2006
KitMaker: 580 posts
Armorama: 499 posts
Posted: Monday, January 26, 2009 - 02:57 AM UTC

Quoted Text

Your selling yourself short. ... I too run into the same challange with the skirts not fitting correctly with the bogies.



Hi Brian,

As with most modelers, I am my own worst critic. Thank you for the vote of confidence.


Quoted Text

Another challange was the gun mantle for the 37mm, this doesn't want to stay in one place.



Mine did not have that problem. You could try wedging shims up against the rotor, just inside each bearing. If glued to the mantlet but not to the rotor, the shims should put friction on the rotor but still allow the gun to elevate.


Quoted Text

The paint is way better than anything I'll ever do.



I used to feel like my painting would never improve. Still do, sometimes. But I keep at it, practice, and force myself to try new things. I keep telling myself that the model I am building now is not the best model I will ever build, so get over it and paint the damn thing.


Quoted Text

According to the wife, a mouse tried to steal it and wage war on her cats.



I wish the mice would steal some of mine. I'll be their arms dealer for free!

-Doug
Damraska
Visit this Community
California, United States
Joined: October 06, 2006
KitMaker: 580 posts
Armorama: 499 posts
Posted: Monday, January 26, 2009 - 03:02 AM UTC

Quoted Text

Nice work! The only thing I don't like are those stripy dust? marks on the sides.



Hi Lars,

Thank you for the feedback and I agree with you--I screwed up on that. I was trying to lay down a random pattern of dried mud with my airbrush, but instead laid down a very obvious zig-zag pattern. I plan on misting some paint over the lower portions of the tank, as per Q's suggestion, and hopefully eliminating the zig-zag patches.

-Doug
tjkelly
Visit this Community
Maryland, United States
Joined: May 04, 2007
KitMaker: 1,132 posts
Armorama: 1,123 posts
Posted: Monday, January 26, 2009 - 08:58 AM UTC
Very nicely done Doug, came out well. Like your camo pattern, don't usually see too many like that, nice change from standard olive drab. Thanks for sharing!

Cheers -
Tim
 _GOTOTOP