"No good" is a broad brush to paint it with. The kit is old and was designed for motorisation. The first left it lacking in detail and the second left the shape of the front of the hull substantially wrong.

Are you the sort of modeller who thinks nothing of sawing off the front of a kit to rebuild it to make it more accurate? If so, then you probably care about the accuracy and may or may not decide to do the substantial amount of work needed to bring this kit up to scratch.

If, on the other hand, you just want a kit to build that goes together pretty well and looks, to the non-AMS eye,just like a Matilda, then this kit is probably just fine for you.

If you can let us know what level of accuracy you want or will fix in a kit, then that will help us evaluate the kit with respect to your needs.

HTH

Paul