Matthew, the title is fine because it caught my attention; the idea is too, especially commendable is your giving credit where it is due because originality is VERY hard to come by these days,anywhere! I think that maybe you are using enamels for painting,if Iīm not mistaken? Well it looks like that maybe they have "gone off".Enamels are great when you open a brand new tin & mix it well ,but then itīs short useful life starts ticking away unless one goes through the trouble of thoroughly cleaning the lid & rim of the tin each time itīs opened.Tamiya acrylics donīt suit my purpose for figure painting either ,so I use Vallejo acrylics,great for mixing ,blending,shading,washes,dry-brushing & they seem to last forever once opened,although handling should be avoided once applied. James is right about the shading but I use different combinations & in no specific order,until it looks ok to me. The colour of the water shouldnīt really be an issue because it looks different depending on angle of view,light conditions ,weather conditions & surrounding areas. I like, & the only technical criticism I can come up with is that he should have a "cammed-up" face. To go about this you should use an extremely watered down colour, transparent even, applied with a fine brush.Practice that method over a flesh colour first & you may find that itīs surprising how transparent it has to be to look effective. Itīs obvious that you enjoy your modelling so let your confidence allow you to be a bit more daring. Weīre all here to share inspiration.
Competing against others there will always be better or worse. Competing against yourself you can only get better,but only, only! if you learn from your mistakes.