Am I better of using straight plaster or should I mix some plaster in with the celluclay to stop or reduce this shrinkage?
Here is a image of the completed base.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2544a/2544ab7252ecacc77c5dc5e8931228921f505e84" alt=""
Here is a closeup showing the shrinkage. Sorry for the blurred image.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e7574/e7574484c68c8e3c4cdd55dedb4eee3a563bb90c" alt=""
In addition to the acrylic paint like you, I add railraod ballast and a big glop of white glue (e.g. Elmer's). Also, I always use wooden bases with holes drilled into them and have no significant shrinkage.
Remember, as the Celluclay cures, water is evaporating from the mixtture and that does reduce some volume. I only add enough moisture in the way of glue, paint and water to get a slurry like very thick oatmeal.
As a corrective, I'd suggest making up some more Celluclay and filling the gap.
I mix the Cel-U-clay with dry wall paste for the liquid additive instead of water. It has water in it but is also a material that drys hard but can be sanded or carved if necessary. Never had a problem with shrinkage. Mix to a very thick oatmeal consistency. I also drill holes in the base so it has something to grab.
C.
![]() |