_GOTOBOTTOM
Armor/AFV: AA/AT/Artillery
For discussions about artillery and anti-aircraft or anti-tank guns.
Hosted by Darren Baker
Masters Productions M4 HST Review
sdk10159
Visit this Community
Oregon, United States
Joined: December 08, 2005
KitMaker: 556 posts
Armorama: 433 posts
Posted: Friday, February 24, 2006 - 05:40 PM UTC
Hi, I thought I'd post this review here in the forums seeing as how I can't get it posted anywhere else.

This is my first full resin kit and first in-box review.

The M4 18 Ton High Speed Tractor was developed during World War Two to tow the 155mm “Long Tom” Gun, the 240mm/8” Howitzers and the 90mm Anti-aircraft gun. This particular kit is molded for the Long Tom and Howitzers. The kit will accent any of the AFV Club offerings of those artillery pieces.

Castings

There are 272 pieces in light gray resin of which 105 are the tracks and four etch sets for the headlight guards. One thing I noticed immediately when I opened the box was the casting plugs. I had heard horror stories from some modelers about the size of the casting plugs and the difficulty in removing them. Most of the parts in this kit don’t have them or they are small to miniscule. The smaller parts are connected to casting blocks via very thin lines. Very few air bubble holes were found, but there is lots of Flash to clean up.

Accuracy

Accuracy appears very good. I’ve not much to go on, as I’ve never seen one of these things in person. However, from the many photos that I’ve seen, online and in books, this looks to be a good rendition. Detail on the kit looks good from the pioneer tools, the bogies, to the inside of the cab. The crew seats even have seat belts molded in.

Detail

Detail is very good. No engine is included and the screens for the engine compartment are solid. I suppose that the holes can be drilled out and a rough engine scratch built that could be seen through the screens.

Instructions

The instructions are decent but vague, in my opinion. Parts are not numbered and one must rely on the diagrams and photo to determine parts and their locations. Some are obvious such as the suspension and superstructure. From the two resin interior sets that I’ve used in the past, I guess this is standard for resin kits.

Cons

There are three major deficiencies and two minor:
- The treads are molded to the drive sprocket and the rear idler wheel.
- No crane for the loading of ammunition.
- No clear styrene for the windscreen.
- The .50 cal machine gun looks too small and the mouting spindle appears to be the wrong type.
- No decals are included.

Recommendation.

Highly recommended. Can’t wait to get started on this. I’ve had a 155mm gun for a long time looking for a companion.

Steve Kubik
 _GOTOTOP