Mallory,
The more wet the plaster is, the more it is likely to shrink or crack. If you are pouring it into a form, the best way is to make it somewhat thick and use a trowel or other tool with a flat, straight edge to smooth it. If it pours, even with the consistancy of syrup, it may still shrink and crack. Remember, the more water in it, the more to evaporate.
Mike (++) (++)