Harv,
Eduard already do a lot of Zimmerit sets, look on the
Eduard website for more details.
Toke,
I have not yet used it on the Brummbaer kit, but I have dry-fitted some parts against a kit, and the fit is good. I have the set for the
Panther D, which I am hoping to build soon, and have attached a number of pieces on that kit. The part that goes on the turret wall follows the curves very well, and the openings for the pistol and communication ports fit perfectly. A more complex shape are the rear stowage boxes, and they are no problem either.
I am not familiar with Atak sets, and have only looked at Cavalier 'in the wrapper' (at a show), so I can't speak from experience. I have been told that they are good, if different, but they are more expensive.
Does this set bear resemblance to the real thing? Well, the pattern is right, if a little simplified, and after it's been painted and weathered it resembles Zimmerit.
We don't do 'comparison' reviews on Armorama, so a review is just that, it tells you what's in the box, if it's correct, if it fits, what it's like to work with. We don't offer an opinion as to which brand is better, as that is a very subjective choice, and something which can (and will...

) be debated for ever. Like here

.
Cheers
Henk