1⁄35A Tale of Three Jeeps
14
Comments
Kits Used
- Tamiya kit 219: Willy’s MB Jeep
- DML kit 6748: Armored Jeep with Bazookas
- Bronco 4x4 GPW with trailer, kit CB-35106
Chassis, Engine and Wheels
At first glance the chassis of the three kits look dimensionally the same. Both DML and Tamiya have the correct round cross strut for the Willy’s and Bronco has the correct U shape, as described above. The most notable difference is in that Tamiya include the lower portion of the engine on the chassis. Detail wise, Bronco’s is the crispest, followed by Tamiya and DML. Bronco uses the first PE part on the chassis, while the other two have no particular add-ons to the chassis. Moving on to the engine, the main portion of this on the Tamiya kit is made up of four parts aside from the lower half included on the chassis. The same portion is made of 12 parts on the DML kit making the engine a much more detailed affair. The Bronco kit uses 20 parts for the same engine making it the most detailed of the three. Next are the axles and drive trains. Tamiya includes the drive trains with the axles and the front axle also includes the steering mechanism. This makes for a very sturdy setup though the detail is of course not as sophisticated as it would be otherwise. DML has the drive trains and steering mechanism separate, making it a more detailed affair and easier to modify to a steering position. The same applies to the Bronco kit, which actually includes three different optional parts for the steering mechanism, making it possible to have steering in neutral, full left and full right. The solutions of the shock absorbers are different in all kits. While Tamiya includes them in the leaf springs, DML has them molded onto the axles and Bronco has them separate. The muffler is included in one part with the protection plate in all three kits. The solution of the connection to the engine is however different in all cases. While Tamiya include the whole muffler in the same part – my personal favorite – DML makes this portion a separate part with the connection under the protection plate – also a good solution. Bronco however makes the connection in plain sight, with lots of care needed to get a clean transition. Overall considering the underside of the vehicle, Tamiya’s is certainly the easiest to build and the sturdiest while Bronco’s is the most detailed though fiddly to build, especially with the steering mechanism. The Wheels on all three kits are all very similar, no particular differences to note except for the Ford embossing on the Bronco kit. All wheels have the same dimensions and tire pattern. Both the DML and Bronco kits give you the full break drums, while the Tamiya kit is much simplified here. Bronco’s wheels can be built to be moveable to facilitate painting.Comments
Great feature, Stefan. No surprise that Bronco kit is the best, but I am a bit surprised that Dragon is THAT bad!
AUG 23, 2013 - 12:00 AM
Thanks guys!
Don't get me wrong, it's not THAT bad, it just doesn't offer any advantage over the other two.
AUG 23, 2013 - 12:16 AM
Great work Stefan !! Very Nice finished Models and very, very interesting comparison test... Especially as I am -slowly- building two tamiya jeeps in order To "up date" them with a Nice résine set from Legend, and a bronco jeep is on Its Way to me via air mail... BRAVO and once again congratulations.
AUG 23, 2013 - 10:00 AM
Wow, this is simply one of the best features we've had on Armorama in some time! GREAT work, Stefan. Terrific detail, superb layout of the build, and some excellent information that will make picking kits much easier for most of us. Thanks!
AUG 24, 2013 - 03:25 AM
Excellent comparisons on all 3! Had been contemplating buying the DML, but now my money would be better spent on Bronco.
AUG 25, 2013 - 08:50 PM
Very good comparison, thanks for the work Stefan!
Great to see the parts next to each other, in many cases that explains more than many words.
Very thorough article on my favorite subject! I have the Tamiya one, and the next is going to be Bronco...
Cheers
Alex
SEP 06, 2013 - 08:44 AM
Awesome article Stefan!
I'm going to be picking up a Bronco kit in the near future and I've got a 1:1 scale 42 GPW in my garage right now. My question though is how does the old Italeri kit compare? I know that the three kits reviewed here are far newer and incorporate a lot of better mold making technology since the Italeri showed up two decades ago.
Thanks!
Jon
SEP 06, 2013 - 11:29 AM
Thank you for the nice comments, gentlemen! I am glad to have been of help.
Jon, can't really say about the Italeri kit. I only built the commandocar long time ago and as I remember it wasn't a bad kit, but not as good as Tamiya. With a bit of TLC I'm sure it can be brought up to speed and versions of it are still widely available and for good prices too.
Cheers!
Stefan
SEP 07, 2013 - 02:52 AM
Hi Stefan,
A very informative article and 3 great results. You put a lot of time and effort into the comparison which will be of great benefit to many.
Congrats on a fine article.
Al
OCT 11, 2013 - 07:13 AM
Copyright ©2021 by Stefan Halter. Images and/or videos also by copyright holder unless otherwise noted. The views and opinions expressed herein are solely the views and opinions of the authors and/or contributors to this Web site and do not necessarily represent the views and/or opinions of Armorama, KitMaker Network, or Silver Star Enterrpises. All rights reserved. Originally published on: 2013-08-22 23:40:59. Unique Reads: 34433