Quoted Text
This is coming along swimmingly... I have a lot of the PPP items too, beautifully cast I must say. Wonderful work so far!
On the chassis -- Trumpeter's entire E50/75 series of kits -- I'm of the opinion they screwed up not understanding tank engineering in general. For starters, I feel all the wheels stations should have at least be fitted with double wheels a la the Panther II, E100, and Tiger II chassis. To me there is no way the tonnage being reported for this chassis series (the E75 would likely have topped 90-tons fully loaded) can survive long in the field on a single thin disc wheel per axle...the wheel bearings alone would have to be magically impressive to handle such stresses as Trumpeter has designed it.
I brought this up to John at PPP and we were in general agreement. Trumpeter's arrangement only looks superficially correct from direct side view as they likely only had that Panzer Tract volume as ref. The suspension also sits way too high on these kits, by how much I don't know exactly, but I've been lowering my kits like a good SoCal car guy should.
Hi, Michael- I AGREE with you 100% regarding TRUMPETER's screwing-up their renditions of the E50/E75 fragile-looking suspension and single-wheel-per-axle. In 1:1 scale, the weight of the tank' hull, turret, etc, would collapse the suspension, unless this paper panzer was truly made out of paper!
Incidentally, I've wound up "dropping" the suspensions on my 1/35 German armor by about 1/8" or so for quite a while. Glad to see that other modellers have noticed 1/35 German armor sitting just a tiny bit high. I've been doing that on some of my US/Allied machines as well...
TRUMPY isn't the only one in getting paper panzers wrong. DRAGON screwed-up the suspension and wheel-placement on their OLD "Panther II" kit. They got the shape of the "Schmallturm" wrong, too. But then, DRAGON was just a child back then... The fix for the turret is easy enough- You can either rob the turret out of a DRAGON "Panther F" kit, or buy the resin ACCURATE ARMOR conversion...
I'm mostly a US/ALLIED builder, but this is still a very interesting thread, and it's great to see how modellers can enlarge on a subject-kit of a "what-if" that never made it off the drawing board...