Armor/AFV
For discussions on tanks, artillery, jeeps, etc.
For discussions on tanks, artillery, jeeps, etc.
Hosted by Darren Baker, Mario Matijasic
Forbidden Models?
long_tom
Illinois, United States
Joined: March 18, 2006
KitMaker: 2,362 posts
Armorama: 2,005 posts
Joined: March 18, 2006
KitMaker: 2,362 posts
Armorama: 2,005 posts
Posted: Sunday, September 03, 2017 - 05:48 AM UTC
I mentioned the subject before, but I happened to note that the Bronco online catalog has stopped listing the Type 63-2 and related Chinese APC kits, though they still list the earlier and export versions. Question: did they get word about those vehicles being used in the Tiananmen Square uprising of 1989, and decided to no longer sell items that could be used to depict this not-to-be-mentioned episode in Chinese history?
Mrclark7
Texas, United States
Joined: June 04, 2017
KitMaker: 503 posts
Armorama: 477 posts
Joined: June 04, 2017
KitMaker: 503 posts
Armorama: 477 posts
Posted: Sunday, September 03, 2017 - 06:32 AM UTC
After living in Germany during my childhood and seeing all the German models having the outside box swastikas blacked out, and ever kit being opended and having its decals dissected of the symbols also.
Not far fetched to me.
Not far fetched to me.
obg153
Texas, United States
Joined: April 07, 2009
KitMaker: 1,063 posts
Armorama: 1,049 posts
Joined: April 07, 2009
KitMaker: 1,063 posts
Armorama: 1,049 posts
Posted: Sunday, September 03, 2017 - 07:00 AM UTC
Questions: Are we looking for conspiracies where none exist? IF this were true, why would it be limited to a single incident in Chinese history? IF this notion were true, why are model companies producing German & Russian afvs in mass quantities, since both countries have questionable episodes related to human rights in their past? IF this were true, many 1/35 kits of rail cars of WWII vintage would also disappear, so no one might be tempted to portray a Holocaust scene. The issue on swastikas is just that; the symbol has been outlawed, not the model that may have displayed that symbol. Come on, people!
BruceJ8365
Kansas, United States
Joined: December 25, 2012
KitMaker: 441 posts
Armorama: 441 posts
Joined: December 25, 2012
KitMaker: 441 posts
Armorama: 441 posts
Posted: Sunday, September 03, 2017 - 07:22 AM UTC
I don't know what you're talking about. There's no such thing as the tiananmen square Incident... it was just a fictitious incident made up by us capitalist pigs.
Mrclark7
Texas, United States
Joined: June 04, 2017
KitMaker: 503 posts
Armorama: 477 posts
Joined: June 04, 2017
KitMaker: 503 posts
Armorama: 477 posts
Posted: Sunday, September 03, 2017 - 08:21 AM UTC
long_tom
Illinois, United States
Joined: March 18, 2006
KitMaker: 2,362 posts
Armorama: 2,005 posts
Joined: March 18, 2006
KitMaker: 2,362 posts
Armorama: 2,005 posts
Posted: Sunday, September 03, 2017 - 05:26 PM UTC
There's also those posters advertising Guinness beer which feature men with toothbrush mustaches...
mmeier
Nordrhein-Westfalen, Germany
Joined: October 22, 2008
KitMaker: 1,280 posts
Armorama: 1,015 posts
Joined: October 22, 2008
KitMaker: 1,280 posts
Armorama: 1,015 posts
Posted: Sunday, September 03, 2017 - 05:51 PM UTC
Quoted Text
After living in Germany during my childhood and seeing all the German models having the outside box swastikas blacked out, and ever kit being opended and having its decals dissected of the symbols also.
Not far fetched to me.
In germany we thankfully have the paragraph 86/86a StGB (German Criminal Laws) that basically forbids the use and sale of symbols like the swastika, sieg-runes and other Nazi crap AND have nice penalties. The use of that crappy symbols is only allowed in a very limited (and clearly defined) context and models are luckily not among the useages (Museum pieces IF the context is educational are an exception).
RobinNilsson
TOS Moderator
Stockholm, Sweden
Joined: November 29, 2006
KitMaker: 6,693 posts
Armorama: 5,562 posts
Joined: November 29, 2006
KitMaker: 6,693 posts
Armorama: 5,562 posts
Posted: Sunday, September 03, 2017 - 06:08 PM UTC
Let's see.
Scalemates lists the following versions:
35082: YW 531C Armored Personnel Carrier with decals for two Iraqi vehicles
35083: YW 750 Armored Ambulance, boxart shows Red Crescent so presumably some muslim country
35086: Type 63-1 (YW-531A) Armored Personnel Carrier (Early Production) with decals for PAVN and PLA
35088: WZ-701 Armoured Command & Control Vehicle (PLA markings shown on box-art ??)
35091: YW-701A Armored Command and Control Vehicle (Gulf War) Iraqi army
35094: Type 63-2 (YW-531B) Armored Personnel Carrier.
Bronco online catalog lists:
35082: YW-531C Armored Personnel Carrier (Export Version) E
35083: YW-750 Armored Ambulance Vehicle (Export Version) E
35086: Type 63-1/YW531A APC (PLA Version) E
35088: WZ701 Armoured Command & Control Vehicle E & C
35091: YW-701A Armored Command & Control Vehicle (Export Version) E
35094: Type 63-2/YW531B APC E & C
Only 35088 and 35091 also have a page with Chinese text, all of the others only have English text(see E, E & C annotation above). All the pure export versions only have an English presentation. The odd one out is 35086 which is labeled as 'PLA version' so there should be a "local" interest.
All versions listed by Scalemates are also listed by Bronco, specifically the Type 63-2. The Type 63-1 on the other hand should possibly also have a presentation page in Chinese but now it only has an English page.
When I entered 'Type 63-2' in Broncos search function it showed me 35094, searching for YW531 returns 35086 + 35094 in English and Chinese (three results). I am fairly certain that a search for the other type-numbers would return the corresponding kits. A search for only 'YW' returns all of them plus some British WW II stuff ....
What's the problem?
/ Robin
Scalemates lists the following versions:
35082: YW 531C Armored Personnel Carrier with decals for two Iraqi vehicles
35083: YW 750 Armored Ambulance, boxart shows Red Crescent so presumably some muslim country
35086: Type 63-1 (YW-531A) Armored Personnel Carrier (Early Production) with decals for PAVN and PLA
35088: WZ-701 Armoured Command & Control Vehicle (PLA markings shown on box-art ??)
35091: YW-701A Armored Command and Control Vehicle (Gulf War) Iraqi army
35094: Type 63-2 (YW-531B) Armored Personnel Carrier.
Bronco online catalog lists:
35082: YW-531C Armored Personnel Carrier (Export Version) E
35083: YW-750 Armored Ambulance Vehicle (Export Version) E
35086: Type 63-1/YW531A APC (PLA Version) E
35088: WZ701 Armoured Command & Control Vehicle E & C
35091: YW-701A Armored Command & Control Vehicle (Export Version) E
35094: Type 63-2/YW531B APC E & C
Only 35088 and 35091 also have a page with Chinese text, all of the others only have English text(see E, E & C annotation above). All the pure export versions only have an English presentation. The odd one out is 35086 which is labeled as 'PLA version' so there should be a "local" interest.
All versions listed by Scalemates are also listed by Bronco, specifically the Type 63-2. The Type 63-1 on the other hand should possibly also have a presentation page in Chinese but now it only has an English page.
When I entered 'Type 63-2' in Broncos search function it showed me 35094, searching for YW531 returns 35086 + 35094 in English and Chinese (three results). I am fairly certain that a search for the other type-numbers would return the corresponding kits. A search for only 'YW' returns all of them plus some British WW II stuff ....
What's the problem?
/ Robin
Removed by original poster on 09/04/17 - 13:22:42 (GMT).
long_tom
Illinois, United States
Joined: March 18, 2006
KitMaker: 2,362 posts
Armorama: 2,005 posts
Joined: March 18, 2006
KitMaker: 2,362 posts
Armorama: 2,005 posts
Posted: Sunday, September 03, 2017 - 06:43 PM UTC
Quoted Text
Quoted TextAfter living in Germany during my childhood and seeing all the German models having the outside box swastikas blacked out, and ever kit being opended and having its decals dissected of the symbols also.
Not far fetched to me.
In germany we thankfully have the paragraph 86/86a StGB (German Criminal Laws) that basically forbids the use and sale of symbols like the swastika, sieg-runes and other Nazi crap AND have nice penalties. The use of that crappy symbols is only allowed in a very limited (and clearly defined) context and models are luckily not among the useages (Museum pieces IF the context is educational are an exception).
When you think about it, few WW2 vehicles actually have swastikas on them. Also, most Wehrmacht soldiers did not have swastikas on their clothing either. I assume other than national flags, they'd only be seen on Party members and the like.
corsutton
Oklahoma, United States
Joined: June 17, 2005
KitMaker: 544 posts
Armorama: 511 posts
Joined: June 17, 2005
KitMaker: 544 posts
Armorama: 511 posts
Posted: Sunday, September 03, 2017 - 06:44 PM UTC
I admit, I am a little curious about this topic as well. I was able to purchase twos sets of the Archer, Islamic Insurgent Flags Syria & Iraq, also known as ISIS Flags. I have a project I would like to do, with a technical, but am not sure how offensive showing the flag would be.
long_tom
Illinois, United States
Joined: March 18, 2006
KitMaker: 2,362 posts
Armorama: 2,005 posts
Joined: March 18, 2006
KitMaker: 2,362 posts
Armorama: 2,005 posts
Posted: Sunday, September 03, 2017 - 06:45 PM UTC
Quoted Text
Let's see.
What's the problem?
/ Robin
So they do still make them, but you have to look for them. I wonder how many Chinese modelers actually make these vehicles, and in what settings.
ReluctantRenegade
Wien, Austria
Joined: March 09, 2016
KitMaker: 2,408 posts
Armorama: 2,300 posts
Joined: March 09, 2016
KitMaker: 2,408 posts
Armorama: 2,300 posts
Posted: Sunday, September 03, 2017 - 06:58 PM UTC
Quoted Text
When you think about it, few WW2 vehicles actually have swastikas on them. Also, most Wehrmacht soldiers did not have swastikas on their clothing either. I assume other than national flags, they'd only be seen on Party members and the like.
I believe Kelly refers to planes/ships in a wider modeling context...
RobinNilsson
TOS Moderator
Stockholm, Sweden
Joined: November 29, 2006
KitMaker: 6,693 posts
Armorama: 5,562 posts
Joined: November 29, 2006
KitMaker: 6,693 posts
Armorama: 5,562 posts
Posted: Sunday, September 03, 2017 - 07:19 PM UTC
Quoted Text
Quoted TextLet's see.
What's the problem?
/ Robin
So they do still make them, but you have to look for them. I wonder how many Chinese modelers actually make these vehicles, and in what settings.
Have to look for them?
Well, for me it was a lot easier to use the search function to locate YW, WZ et.c but I just tried going through the online catalogue page-by-page, check page 12 (4 kits), page 31 and 32 (one kit each)
http://www.cn-bronco.com/en/products.php?page=12
http://www.cn-bronco.com/en/products.php?page=31
http://www.cn-bronco.com/en/products.php?page=32
It took me a few minutes and reminded me about some kits that I would like to add to the stash
They do have a strange catalogue with scales mixed seemingly randomly, 1:35 and then some 1:350 and back to 1:35 again et.c.
Could that be the root of the problem? Stopped flipping pages when the first ship turned up?
/ Robin
Scarred
Washington, United States
Joined: March 11, 2016
KitMaker: 1,792 posts
Armorama: 1,186 posts
Joined: March 11, 2016
KitMaker: 1,792 posts
Armorama: 1,186 posts
Posted: Sunday, September 03, 2017 - 07:47 PM UTC
Quoted Text
I admit, I am a little curious about this topic as well. I was able to purchase twos sets of the Archer, Islamic Insurgent Flags Syria & Iraq, also known as ISIS Flags. I have a project I would like to do, with a technical, but am not sure how offensive showing the flag would be.
Do you want to build it? Then do it, don't worry about overly sensitive people.
BTW did you read this thread? It's funny and deals about this very thing. http://armorama.com/forums/249732&ord=&page=1
corsutton
Oklahoma, United States
Joined: June 17, 2005
KitMaker: 544 posts
Armorama: 511 posts
Joined: June 17, 2005
KitMaker: 544 posts
Armorama: 511 posts
Posted: Sunday, September 03, 2017 - 07:55 PM UTC
Scarred, I read that thread and immediately went to eBay. I bought the last two that I could find on there.
Sergas
Ontario, Canada
Joined: April 13, 2017
KitMaker: 51 posts
Armorama: 37 posts
Joined: April 13, 2017
KitMaker: 51 posts
Armorama: 37 posts
Posted: Sunday, September 03, 2017 - 08:01 PM UTC
Quoted Text
Quoted TextQuoted TextAfter living in Germany during my childhood and seeing all the German models having the outside box swastikas blacked out, and ever kit being opended and having its decals dissected of the symbols also.
Not far fetched to me.
In germany we thankfully have the paragraph 86/86a StGB (German Criminal Laws) that basically forbids the use and sale of symbols like the swastika, sieg-runes and other Nazi crap AND have nice penalties. The use of that crappy symbols is only allowed in a very limited (and clearly defined) context and models are luckily not among the useages (Museum pieces IF the context is educational are an exception).
When you think about it, few WW2 vehicles actually have swastikas on them. Also, most Wehrmacht soldiers did not have swastikas on their clothing either. I assume other than national flags, they'd only be seen on Party members and the like.
The German Helmet and belt buckle had a Swastika on them. Also any kind of German Medals, of that time period, is forbidden in Germany unless you remove the Swastika. But it is still considered a "Nazi" item. And the German public does not like old veterans showing their Medals, that most of them got for a reason (like any other Men fighting for their country)
Here is a Video that i find really interesting and sad at the same time: Tank Veterans
redcap
England - East Midlands, United Kingdom
Joined: November 06, 2005
KitMaker: 753 posts
Armorama: 378 posts
Joined: November 06, 2005
KitMaker: 753 posts
Armorama: 378 posts
Posted: Sunday, September 03, 2017 - 08:03 PM UTC
This whole Political Correctness C**p and social disease is utter nonsense and yet only seems to be raised and debated within the AFV modelling circles and invariably regarding SS and Nazi stuff (never a mention of cuddly old 'Uncle Joe's' red star armour or units as he / they never hurt a soul!)
I mean, you never see these debates or expressions of angst within the figure community where I also model discussing whether a magnificently painted figure or bust of, say, Genghis Khan is 'inappropriate' because his hordes killed millions or likewise of someone like Julius Caesar because he effectively committed genocide in ancient Gaul.
Let's just build our models and figures chaps and enjoy the hobby for what it is and leave the 'theology' and 'ethics' of it all to the teenaged kids - where everything thus far in their lives has been "free" - propping up the student union bars into the early hours and whilst convincing themselves mid diatribe of their moral superiority.
Gary
I mean, you never see these debates or expressions of angst within the figure community where I also model discussing whether a magnificently painted figure or bust of, say, Genghis Khan is 'inappropriate' because his hordes killed millions or likewise of someone like Julius Caesar because he effectively committed genocide in ancient Gaul.
Let's just build our models and figures chaps and enjoy the hobby for what it is and leave the 'theology' and 'ethics' of it all to the teenaged kids - where everything thus far in their lives has been "free" - propping up the student union bars into the early hours and whilst convincing themselves mid diatribe of their moral superiority.
Gary
Biggles2
Quebec, Canada
Joined: January 01, 2004
KitMaker: 7,600 posts
Armorama: 6,110 posts
Joined: January 01, 2004
KitMaker: 7,600 posts
Armorama: 6,110 posts
Posted: Sunday, September 03, 2017 - 08:04 PM UTC
Quoted Text
... Also, most Wehrmacht soldiers did not have swastikas on their clothing either...
Every Wehrmacht member (Kriegsmarine, Luftwaffe, et al.) wore a Swastika - on their uniform chest eagle: http://www.epicmilitaria.com/media/catalog/category/resize/heerfieldgreytuniceagle.jpg
mmeier
Nordrhein-Westfalen, Germany
Joined: October 22, 2008
KitMaker: 1,280 posts
Armorama: 1,015 posts
Joined: October 22, 2008
KitMaker: 1,280 posts
Armorama: 1,015 posts
Posted: Sunday, September 03, 2017 - 08:51 PM UTC
Quoted Text
This whole Political Correctness C**p and social disease is utter nonsense and yet only seems to be raised and debated within the AFV modelling circles and invariably regarding SS and Nazi stuff (never a mention of cuddly old 'Uncle Joe's' red star armour or units as he / they never hurt a soul!)
I mean, you never see these debates or expressions of angst within the figure community where I also model discussing whether a magnificently painted figure or bust of, say, Genghis Khan is 'inappropriate' because his hordes killed millions or likewise of someone like Julius Caesar because he effectively committed genocide in ancient Gaul.
Let's just build our models and figures chaps and enjoy the hobby for what it is and leave the 'theology' and 'ethics' of it all to the teenaged kids - where everything thus far in their lives has been "free" - propping up the student union bars into the early hours and whilst convincing themselves mid diatribe of their moral superiority.
Gary
The german 86/86a StGB is a LOT older than "Political Correctness". And it does cover a lot more than the Nazis. EVERY organisation that was ruled illegeal by germanies highest court (and believe me you have to work REALLY hard to get that "honor") is covered. And when it comes to Nazis it covers not only the Swastica but also a number of unit symbols, greetings, songs etc.
Btw: That is also the reason the Red Star is not illegal - the UdSSR is not an organisation. The Kommunist Party in D was AND is illegal.
Given that the Allies sadly left a viable breeding population of Nazis intact in germany the 86/86a is a much needed and finally much used law these days (The record is over a hundered cases opened in one day on a Nazi concert recently)
long_tom
Illinois, United States
Joined: March 18, 2006
KitMaker: 2,362 posts
Armorama: 2,005 posts
Joined: March 18, 2006
KitMaker: 2,362 posts
Armorama: 2,005 posts
Posted: Sunday, September 03, 2017 - 09:28 PM UTC
I was thinking less about what offends the nations in which you build the models in than who supplies the models. China might not be pleased when they sell models of Type 63s and they depict the Tiananmen Square incident. They might be pleased if somebody depicts them invading Vietnam though. They in fact sell the figures from that era.
Luftan
Aichi-ken, Japan / 日本
Joined: June 04, 2016
KitMaker: 87 posts
Armorama: 76 posts
Joined: June 04, 2016
KitMaker: 87 posts
Armorama: 76 posts
Posted: Sunday, September 03, 2017 - 10:55 PM UTC
I was wondering about trumpeter 1/350 the other day.
They make tons of 1/350 ship model every year, but never a subject of ww2 era IJN war-ships. IJN has a big following amongst modellers with its wide variety of interesting subjects, and I have hard time understanding why Trumpeter neglects this genre.
The only explanation I could think of was the fact that Trumpy is a Chinese company, and China didn't exactly had good relationship with Japan back then
They make tons of 1/350 ship model every year, but never a subject of ww2 era IJN war-ships. IJN has a big following amongst modellers with its wide variety of interesting subjects, and I have hard time understanding why Trumpeter neglects this genre.
The only explanation I could think of was the fact that Trumpy is a Chinese company, and China didn't exactly had good relationship with Japan back then
GarethM
Ontario, Canada
Joined: January 28, 2015
KitMaker: 119 posts
Armorama: 118 posts
Joined: January 28, 2015
KitMaker: 119 posts
Armorama: 118 posts
Posted: Sunday, September 03, 2017 - 11:08 PM UTC
I assume it has more to do with low sales than the Tiananmen Square incident.
If that were the case, then you would have to wonder how Trumpeter would allow you to build Type 59s as seen in the most iconic photos taken that day straight out of the box.
If that were the case, then you would have to wonder how Trumpeter would allow you to build Type 59s as seen in the most iconic photos taken that day straight out of the box.
Sleepwalker71
Singapore / 新加坡
Joined: August 30, 2012
KitMaker: 265 posts
Armorama: 186 posts
Joined: August 30, 2012
KitMaker: 265 posts
Armorama: 186 posts
Posted: Sunday, September 03, 2017 - 11:15 PM UTC
Quoted Text
The german 86/86a StGB is a LOT older than "Political Correctness". And it does cover a lot more than the Nazis. EVERY organisation that was ruled illegeal by germanies highest court (and believe me you have to work REALLY hard to get that "honor") is covered. And when it comes to Nazis it covers not only the Swastica but also a number of unit symbols, greetings, songs etc.
Btw: That is also the reason the Red Star is not illegal - the UdSSR is not an organisation. The Kommunist Party in D was AND is illegal.
Given that the Allies sadly left a viable breeding population of Nazis intact in germany the 86/86a is a much needed and finally much used law these days (The record is over a hundered cases opened in one day on a Nazi concert recently)
So, how you explain existence of NPD in Germany even when Office of Protection of Constitution as well as other authorities recognised that its roots and background are neo-nazi. It sounds for me a bit weird while models cannot carry specific symbols.
Tojo72
North Carolina, United States
Joined: June 06, 2006
KitMaker: 4,691 posts
Armorama: 3,509 posts
Joined: June 06, 2006
KitMaker: 4,691 posts
Armorama: 3,509 posts
Posted: Monday, September 04, 2017 - 01:29 AM UTC
Quoted Text
Quoted TextQuoted TextAfter living in Germany during my childhood and seeing all the German models having the outside box swastikas blacked out, and ever kit being opended and having its decals dissected of the symbols also.
Not far fetched to me.
In germany we thankfully have the paragraph 86/86a StGB (German Criminal Laws) that basically forbids the use and sale of symbols like the swastika, sieg-runes and other Nazi crap AND have nice penalties. The use of that crappy symbols is only allowed in a very limited (and clearly defined) context and models are luckily not among the useages (Museum pieces IF the context is educational are an exception).
When you think about it, few WW2 vehicles actually have swastikas on them. Also, most Wehrmacht soldiers did not have swastikas on their clothing either. I assume other than national flags, they'd only be seen on Party members and the like.
Surprisingly the supposedly least Nazified unit in the Heer,the Afrika Korp had the palm tree and swatiska on their vehicles,which I think is a pretty cool insignia except for the swatiska.