Thanks for posting those info links a few posts further back Nick, I'd seen most but enjoyed watching the Zaloga/Doyle discussion.
However ..... this has to be done.
Funny thing, this- didn't we Yank colonists quite decisively settle the matter of arbitrary British searches back in 1783- you know- that "Yankee Doodle" thing? It was in all the papers, on both sides of the "Pond."
The book has something like 300-plus sources and 1300-plus footnotes. You're more than welcome to peruse them when it's out.
For now, can't let the cat out of the bag, as we colonists say...
Funny thing, this- didn't we Yank colonists quite decisively settle the matter of arbitrary British searches back in 1783- you know- that "Yankee Doodle" thing? It was in all the papers, on both sides of the "Pond."
The book has something like 300-plus sources and 1300-plus footnotes. You're more than welcome to peruse them when it's out.
For now, can't let the cat out of the bag, as we colonists say...
PS I'm not familiar with Mr. Simpson, nor have I communicated with him.
PS- Yes, I'm the author! Best, Christian M. DeJohn
The fact that the 76 MM armed M4A1s all remained in depot during the assault on France, that despite having other weapons available, the US army went into France knowing it was going to encounter Tigers (despite the fact they largely did not), and despite that fact it went in equipped with Shermans with 75 MM guns, M10s with 3 inches, and the lamentable towed pieces of similar caliber (plus the 57 mm).
Quoted TextPS- Yes, I'm the author! Best, Christian M. DeJohn
Wait.... YOU'RE the author? Gee I never would've known... Thanks for clearing that up.Quoted TextThe fact that the 76 MM armed M4A1s all remained in depot during the assault on France, that despite having other weapons available, the US army went into France knowing it was going to encounter Tigers (despite the fact they largely did not), and despite that fact it went in equipped with Shermans with 75 MM guns, M10s with 3 inches, and the lamentable towed pieces of similar caliber (plus the 57 mm).
Like I said before, the 3in gun was similar to the 76mm. They are of very similar caliber: 3 inches = 76.2mm. Some rounds had similar penetrating power. I don't think the 3 in M7 can be counted as a poor gun that is subpar to the 76mm M1A1/A1C/A2.
Quoted TextThanks for posting those info links a few posts further back Nick, I'd seen most but enjoyed watching the Zaloga/Doyle discussion.
However ..... this has to be done.
That Tiger is towing one that has been knocked out.
I am very well aware of that, shows excellent unit discipline under fire as well as impressing the cat.
Quoted Text
I am very well aware of that, shows excellent unit discipline under fire as well as impressing the cat.
They are not under fire.
they are in a combat zone, the other Tiger has been "knocked out" .... they aren't in Paris, near enough for the cat.
Quoted Text
they are in a combat zone, the other Tiger has been "knocked out" .... they aren't in Paris, near enough for the cat.
Photo was taken after 4th CLY withdrew back to the Amaye area some 4-5km to the west. Pz Lehr were between SS 101 and the nearest Allied forces.
Quoted TextFunny thing, this- didn't we Yank colonists quite decisively settle the matter of arbitrary British searches back in 1783- you know- that "Yankee Doodle" thing? It was in all the papers, on both sides of the "Pond."
The book has something like 300-plus sources and 1300-plus footnotes. You're more than welcome to peruse them when it's out.
For now, can't let the cat out of the bag, as we colonists say...
I am Irish so you your barbs are wasted on me.
I simply asked what were the sources you used and it seems this s a problem for you.
I just wanted to know what you were using to draw your conclusion and unless you have found a room full of previously unknown period documentation I do not understand your reticence. This path is well worn by many and I am confident you bring nothing new in the way of fact.
Your bombast echoes that of Gary L. Simpson and you seem to have a lot in common.
The current theory over on tanknet is that this book is his, rejected as ridiculous masters thesis, with lots of color pictures.
Like I said before, the 3in gun was similar to the 76mm. They are of very similar caliber: 3 inches = 76.2mm. Some rounds had similar penetrating power. I don't think the 3 in M7 can be counted as a poor gun that is subpar to the 76mm M1A1/A1C/A2.
Maybe we should read page 340 of Col. Robert Allen's book "Lucky Forward". Gen Eisenhower talked about the tankers coming home and telling relatives how the Sherman stood up to the Panthers and Tigers. Eisenhower want the public relations officers to create good stories to combat the experiences of the tankers.
I have just one question to all. What type would you want to be in. A Panther or Tiger or a Sherman?
Knowing just how dishonest the Nazis could be, I’m not even sure if I trust that 30 [Tigers] got [to Africa]
 |
